Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus Vs Nitto Ridge Grappler tires being compared here, Pirelli Scorpion AT Plus, an All-Terrain tire, and Nitto Ridge Grappler, a hybrid of All-Terrain and Mud-Terrain tires.
The Scorpion AT plus tire features a distinctive rectangular tread pattern and wide groove spacing that enhances its performance on rough terrain, while the Ridge grappler tire features relatively narrow groove spacing for maximum road traction.
Here you can read about the interesting features of both beasts.
Table of Contents
Comparing Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus Vs Nitto Ridge Grappler
Perilli Scorpion All-terrain tires feature an innovative five-pitch tread pattern that offers impressive off-road performance as well as reliability on asphalt roads. The aggressive groove spacing increases the void ratio, so it can be used for off-road adventures without compromising safety or comfort.
A sipes pattern spread across the tread blocks works efficiently in wet conditions by wiping away the water and maintaining traction.
A wider groove spacing helps the tire evacuate mud, snow, and small stones from the pattern and promotes self-cleaning of the tire. The M+S (3PMSF) marking and the three peaks mountain snowflake make it suitable for off-road adventures.
The tread pattern on Nitto tires has an ingenious method of dividing tread blocks at angles. This helps to increase the contact patch of the tire while maintaining a maximum number of grooves between the pattern.
As a result of the relatively low void ratio, Nitto has a greater area in contact with the road, which provides adequate grip without compromising the handling and stability of the vehicle. The lower groove spacing reduces rolling resistance, reducing braking distance and improving its efficiency at high speeds.
In wet conditions, the sipes pattern wipes away the water and maintains traction. The hybrid tread design improves the tire’s quietness and comfort on highways, while the aggressive shoulders and sidewall lugs make it better off-road.
Traction when driving on the road
Tires with a larger contact patch will provide better traction on the road. With relatively wider tread blocks, the Scorpion has a decent contact patch, but the wider spacing between the tread blocks reduces the surface area in contact with the road to some degree.
As a result, the grip and handling of the tire are compromised at high speeds, and the brake distance is increased. However, the deeper grooves give this tire an edge on wet surfaces as the 3D sipes technology wipes away water and cleans the tire to maintain maximum traction.
Asphalt roads are best suited to Nitto’s dynamic tread design. The increased contact patch enhances the grip on dry roads.
At higher speeds, the lower void ratio reduces rolling resistance and improves efficiency.
In dry conditions, the densely packed tread blocks ensure smooth and comfortable driving. In wet conditions, the deep Sipes perpendicular to the grooves play an important role in maintaining traction with the road.
Both tires perform adequately on highways and paved roads, but Nitto has a larger contact patch that provides a more comfortable and reliable ride in dry conditions, while Scorpion is slightly better in wet conditions.
The off-road traction
Tires’ off-road characteristics are primarily determined by the groove spacing and shoulder width. Scorpion is dominant in mud terrains because the high void ratio allows smooth navigation through swamps by throwing chunks of mud backward, clearing the path for the tire to move forward.
As a result, the tire does not get stuck and keeps rolling as the wide grooves prevent mud from getting stuck between them.
In mild muddy swamps, Nitto’s performance in mud terrain is just fine due to its decent void ratio. A prominent shoulder design contributes to its mud traction by evacuating mud and clearing a path for the tire.
It can be used on light mud surfaces, but its grip and handling could be compromised in extreme mud conditions as the soft mud could fill up the narrow grooves causing the tire to get stuck.
A Scorpion tire is better suited to muddy terrains because of its high void ratio and wider tread pattern compared to a Nitto tire.
When traversing through soft snow areas, Scorpion does not have to struggle much as the wider groove channels propel the tire forward by biting into the snow and scooping it out.
As a result of the higher void ratio, no snow gets accumulated between the rectangular tread blocks, ensuring maximum traction. Due to its limited contact patch, however, this tire is less efficient on ice.
As Nitto’s tread pattern has a relatively low void ratio, it struggles a bit on soft snow surfaces. Because of its narrow grooves, it cannot effectively scoop out all the snow, making it unsuitable for soft snow.
The larger contact patch, however, performs better in icy conditions, as the numerous tread blocks and sipes pattern provide maximum grip and smooth navigation.
As a result of the tire’s toughness and rigidity, as well as its stone ejectors, it is useful in rocky areas. The Scorpion tire features a robust compound that makes it tough enough to handle rocky terrain.
Stone ejectors along the edges of tread blocks ensure no stones get stuck in the grooves. Having a higher void ratio also contributes to tire self-cleaning.
With the dynamic tread design, Nitto tires perform well on mild rocky areas, as the cut pattern of the tread blocks helps them maintain traction and propagate well, while the stone ejectors are helpful in clearing out stones and pebbles from the grooves.
It is recommended not to use this tire in extremely rough conditions, as the stones could get stuck in the narrow grooves channel causing stone drilling, which may result in permanent damage to the tread blocks.
In rocky terrain, scorpion is more preferred as the wider grooves provide better grip and handling while traversing uneven terrain.
Comfort While Driving
The Scorpion has relatively wide grooves, which reduces comfort on paved roads. As a result of the high void ratio, the air gets trapped inside the grooves of the tire and hits the walls of the tread blocks repeatedly, making the tire more noisy.
As a result of the wide groove channel, this tire does not perform well at high speeds and compromises comfort.
Nitto will not let you down when it comes to a smooth and comfortable ride. The exclusive tread design makes the tire quieter than its competitors and provides a more enjoyable ride.
As a result of Nitto’s advanced 3D simulation technology, the tire is virtually inaudible and does not produce much noise at high speeds.
Treadwear and Durability
Scorpion features an aggressive tread pattern and a bold sidewall design for better off-road performance while maintaining adequate traction on road. For efficient self-cleaning, it features conical stone ejectors that prevent stone drilling and tire damage.
The wide groove channel provides excellent traction in mud and snow by clearing the path of the tire without a lot of effort. This tire provides an impressive mileage of about 60,000 miles due to its robust compound.
With a dynamic cut pattern tread design and 3-ply sidewall construction, the Nitto tire is tough and durable.
The blocks are reinforced with an additional layer of thick rubber. Nitto tires offer the benefits of both All-Terrain and Mud-Terrain tires, and provide an overall satisfactory performance.
However, tread life is somewhat compromised. A larger tread patch means more treadwear, which reduces tread life. A smooth mileage of 40,000-45,000 miles is not bad, but it is less than its rival.
Prices of Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus Vs Nitto Ridge Grappler
Nitto is more expensive than Scorpion because of its excellent on-road traction while delivering adequate off-road capabilities. Scorpion is better off-road, but its performance on paved roads is not so impressive due to its smaller contact patch.
Brief Summary of Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus Vs Nitto Ridge Grappler
- Pirelli Scorpion AT Plus is an All-Terrain Tire, while Nitto is a hybrid of Mud-Terrain and All-Terrain tires.
- On paved roads where more speed is required, Nitto performs much better.
- Scorpions have more wide grooves that make them ideal for mud and snow terrain.
- At high speeds, Nitto provides a more comfortable ride and better handling.
- Its exceptional on-road performance and adequate off-road performance make Nitto a bit more expensive than Scorpion.
Video Comparison of Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus Vs Nitto Ridge Grappler
References and Resources: